Lease Disputes

Lease dispute

Lease dispute

What are Lease Disputes?

After a gruelling process of trying to get your business off the ground, you’ve finally made some progress. Securing your commercial property is the first step in turning an idea into a business. You’ve given your references, signed your lease and paid your deposit. However, what happens if your landlord is nowhere to be found when the property needs maintenance? Or if they refuse to repair or replace structural damage?

When certain aspects of your lease agreement are not met, disputes can form. There are many different scenarios in which a dispute can rise from a commercial property and its lease agreement. They usually stem from common ground elements of the lease that have been signed and agreed upon. This can include property maintenance, building repair, rise in rent, installed fixture removal and so on. Further, there are factors such as loss of quiet enjoyment and relief of forfeiture that are in place to protect the tenant and are lease disputes that they can raise. 

Under Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act (CTA), both the tenant and the landlord have rights and responsibilities that protect them. This act is in place to outline the relationship, rights, and obligations between commercial landlords and tenants. If these rights and responsibilities, or terms of the lease, are ignored or abused then there are grounds for a lease dispute and legal action could be necessary

The rights and obligations

The CTA lays out obligations and responsibilities to ensure that each lease agreement provides an inclusive and comfortable tenancy for both parties. The CTA covers what the landlord is obligated to do for the tenants and their property. While also outlining what the tenants are obligated to do to meet their landlord’s agreement.

These points are general, and just the bare necessities. Yet they provide information on how a lease dispute can arise from negligence of rights and obligations.

The rights and obligations of the landlord include:

  • The right to terminate tenancy if tenants fail to fulfill their outlined obligation.
  • The right of reentry. This is where the grantor of the land has the right to take back property if a specific condition is not met.
    • An example of this is if the land granted is not being used for a specific, agreed upon, function.
  • The right to distraint for rent. This means that the landlord can seize tenant possessions as a means of obtaining payment of rent, or other money owed.
  • The right to apply to the Superior Court of Justice to seek damages for loss of rental income
    • The application may also go to Small Claims Court to seek the balance owed under the lease agreement
  • The mandatory obligation to provide notification of a breach of lease
    • This must be done with reasonable time left for tenants to comply

The rights and responsibilities of the tenant include:

  • The right to take any financial dispute with a landlord to Small Claim Courts, permitting that the dispute of money or personal property is under $25,000
    • If it is over $25,000 then an application to the Superior Court of Justice must be made
  • The obligation to pay rent to the landlord on the agreed due date within the lease
  • The obligation to not hold back rent if the landlord has not fulfilled their obligations of the lease

Things to keep in mind

Always be sure of what you are signing. Every case and every lease is different. In some instances, your lease agreement may take precedence over what is laid out in the CTA. You can be at a disadvantage as a tenant if you are unsure of the lease, and not aware of your obligations.

Any aspect of the commercial property and what its intended purpose will be should be outlined in detail. This ensures that both the landlord and the tenant are on the same page.

Seeking legal counsel may be your best option. Especially if your rights and responsibilities as a landlord or a tenant are being abused. Also, if the basic agreements in your lease are being ignored or overruled. There are so many variables that can cause a lease dispute. Fortunately, Hummingbird Law’s Civil Litigation Team can help you see how unique your situation is. This allows you to decide your best course of action when seeking a court’s interjection.

Whether it is to seek damages in small claims court, or applying to the Superior Court of Justice, Hummingbird Lawyers can stand alongside you to ensure that you find a timely and cost-effective resolution. Contact Hummingbird Lawyers today to request a consultation, or for more information on litigation services.

Hummingbird Lawyers

Hummingbird Lawyers strategically assists businesses and individuals in the areas of corporate law, commercial and residential real estate transactions, wills and estates, employment law and commercial and family law litigation.

Be first to comment