Estate Administration vs. Estate Litigation: Which Service Do You Need?

Estate Administration vs. Estate Litigation: Which Service Do You Need?

Understanding Your Estate Legal Needs in Ontario

Estate Administration vs. Estate Litigation | When dealing with a loved one’s estate in Ontario, you may find yourself needing legal assistance—but do you need help with estate administration or estate litigation? While both fall under the umbrella of estates law, they serve fundamentally different purposes and address distinct situations.

At Hummingbird Lawyers, we frequently help clients navigate this question. Understanding the difference between these two services is crucial because it determines how we can best support you during what is often an emotional and complex time.

This comprehensive guide will help you understand:

• What estate administration and estate litigation each involve
• Key differences between the two services
• Clear indicators of which service you need
• When you might need both
• How Hummingbird Lawyers can support you through either process

What Is Estate Administration?

Estate administration is the standard, orderly process of settling a deceased person’s affairs when there are no disputes or conflicts. It’s what most people think of as “probate” or handling an estate.

The Core Purpose of Estate Administration

Estate administration ensures that:

• The deceased’s assets are properly collected and valued
• Outstanding debts, taxes, and expenses are paid
• The remaining estate is distributed to the rightful beneficiaries
• All legal requirements are met throughout the process

Think of estate administration as the roadmap for executors (also called estate trustees in Ontario) to fulfill their legal duties efficiently and correctly.

What Does Estate Administration Involve?

When you work with Hummingbird Lawyers on estate administration, we guide you through:

1. Obtaining Probate (Certificate of Appointment)

• Preparing and filing all required court documents
• Applying for a Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee (formerly called “Letters of Probate”)
• For foreign executors: Resealing probate or obtaining a grant of probate in Ontario
• Calculating and paying Estate Administration Tax (probate fees)

2. Collecting and Managing Estate Assets

• Identifying all assets (real estate, bank accounts, investments, personal property)
• Securing and protecting estate assets
• Obtaining valuations where necessary
• Opening estate bank accounts

3. Paying Estate Debts and Obligations

• Notifying creditors
• Reviewing and paying valid claims
• Filing the deceased’s final tax return
• Filing estate tax returns if applicable
• Obtaining a clearance certificate from the Canada Revenue Agency

4. Distributing the Estate

• Interpreting will provisions correctly
• Calculating each beneficiary’s entitlement
• Transferring or selling real estate
• Distributing personal property and financial assets
• Obtaining releases from beneficiaries

5. Passing of Accounts

• Preparing a detailed accounting of all estate transactions
• Providing accounts to beneficiaries
• Obtaining court approval if necessary or requested

When Do You Need Estate Administration Services?

You need estate administration assistance when:

✓ You’ve been named as executor and need guidance on your legal duties
✓ The process seems overwhelming and you want professional support
✓ You’re unsure about probate requirements in your specific situation
✓ The estate has complex assets (multiple properties, business interests, foreign assets)
✓ You’re a foreign executor dealing with Ontario assets
✓ You want to avoid making costly mistakes that could expose you to personal liability
✓ Beneficiaries are requesting a formal accounting
✓ You need limited assistance with specific tasks (probate application, real estate transfers, tax filings)

Key indicator: If everyone agrees on the will’s validity and who should serve as executor, and beneficiaries generally agree on the distribution, you likely need estate administration services.

What Is Estate Litigation?

Estate litigation involves resolving disputes and conflicts related to an estate through legal proceedings. When parties cannot agree, estate litigation becomes necessary to protect rights and obtain court direction.

The Core Purpose of Estate Litigation

Estate litigation addresses situations such as:

• The validity of a will is being questioned
• There are disputes about who should serve as executor
• Beneficiaries disagree about asset distribution
• An executor is not fulfilling their duties properly
• Someone believes they’re entitled to support from the estate
• There are concerns about elder abuse or undue influence

Think of estate litigation as the problem-solving and dispute-resolution arm of estate law—it steps in when cooperation breaks down and legal intervention is required.

What Does Estate Litigation Involve?

When you work with Hummingbird Lawyers on estate litigation, we handle:

1. Will Challenges

• Lack of testamentary capacity: Arguing the deceased lacked mental capacity to make or change their will
• Undue influence: Proving someone improperly influenced the deceased’s testamentary decisions
• Improper execution: Challenging whether the will meets formal legal requirements
• Suspicious circumstances: Investigating unusual changes or circumstances around will creation
• Forgery or fraud: Proving the will is not authentic

2. Dependant Support Claims

• Representing dependants who were financially reliant on the deceased
• Pursuing claims under Part V of Ontario’s Succession Law Reform Act
• Defending estates against dependant support claims
• Negotiating settlements or presenting cases in court

3. Executor Disputes and Accountability

• Executor removal applications: Seeking to remove an executor who is breaching their duties
• Defending removal applications: Protecting an executor’s right to serve
• Passing of accounts disputes: Challenging or defending estate accountings
• Breach of fiduciary duty claims: Holding executors accountable for misconduct
• Executor deadlock: Resolving disputes between co-executors who cannot agree

4. Beneficiary Disputes

• Disagreements over will interpretation
• Disputes about asset valuations
• Conflicts over distribution timing or methods
• Claims that beneficiaries are not receiving their proper entitlements

5. Power of Attorney Disputes

• Challenging the validity of powers of attorney
• Addressing concerns about POA misuse or abuse
• Requiring attorneys to provide accounting of financial decisions
• Applications to remove or replace attorneys

6. Guardianship Applications

• Applying to become guardian of property or person for an incapable adult
• Disputing guardianship appointments
• Addressing concerns about guardian conduct

7. Elder Law Issues

• Financial abuse of elderly individuals
• Capacity assessments
• Protection of vulnerable adults

8. Applications for Directions

• Seeking court guidance on complex or ambiguous will provisions
• Obtaining court approval for significant estate decisions
• Resolving uncertainty about legal interpretation

When Do You Need Estate Litigation Services?

You need estate litigation assistance when:

✓ Someone is challenging the validity of the will
✓ You believe the will is invalid due to lack of capacity, undue influence, or improper execution
✓ There’s a dispute about who should be executor
✓ The executor is not doing their job or is acting improperly
✓ The executor is refusing to provide information or account for their actions
✓ You were financially dependent on the deceased and believe you’re entitled to support from the estate
✓ Beneficiaries cannot agree on major estate decisions
✓ You suspect elder abuse or financial exploitation occurred
✓ The executor is treating beneficiaries unfairly
✓ You need the court to interpret an ambiguous will provision
✓ There’s a conflict between the will and a power of attorney
✓ Co-executors are deadlocked and cannot make decisions
✓ Someone is preventing you from receiving your inheritance

Key indicator: If there is active disagreement, conflict, or the need for court intervention, you need estate litigation services.

Key Differences: Estate Administration vs. Estate Litigation

Real-World Scenarios: Which Service Do You Need?

Scenario 1: Straightforward Estate Administration

Situation: Your mother passed away, leaving a clear will naming you as executor. Your two siblings are cooperative and agree with the will’s terms. The estate includes a house, some investments, and personal property.

What You Need: Estate Administration Services

Why: There are no disputes. You simply need professional guidance to:

• Apply for probate properly
• Understand your duties as executor
• Handle tax filings correctly
• Transfer assets appropriately
• Provide proper accounting to beneficiaries

Hummingbird Lawyer’s Role: We provide executor services, guiding you through each step, handling probate, and ensuring you meet all legal obligations without personal liability.

Scenario 2: Will Challenge

Situation: Your father remarried late in life. After his death, a new will surfaces leaving everything to his second wife, cutting out his three children completely. The will was made after his Alzheimer’s diagnosis, upon his deathbed, and none of the children knew about it.

What You Need: Estate Litigation Services

Why: You need to challenge the will’s validity based on:

• Lack of testamentary capacity (he did not understand the document signed)
• Potential undue influence by the new spouse
• Suspicious circumstances around the will’s creation (signed upon his deathbed)

Hummingbird Lawyer’s Role: We represent you in court proceedings, gathering medical evidence, interviewing witnesses, and presenting a case to challenge the will’s validity.

Scenario 3: Executor Misconduct

Situation: Your uncle was named executor of your grandmother’s estate two years ago. He refuses to provide information about the estate, won’t say when distributions will occur, and beneficiaries suspect he’s using estate funds for personal expenses. He’s been living in grandmother’s house rent-free and may have sold assets without proper authority.

What You Need: Estate Litigation Services

Why: The executor is breaching his fiduciary duties. You need to:

• Compel him to pass accounts (provide detailed accounting)
• Potentially seek his removal as executor
• Recover any misappropriated funds
• Obtain court orders requiring proper estate administration

Hummingbird Lawyers’s Role: We initiate litigation to hold the executor accountable, seek his removal if warranted, and ensure the estate is properly administered going forward.

Scenario 4: Dependant Support Claim

Situation: Your common-law partner of 15 years passed away. His will leaves everything to his adult children from a previous marriage. You were financially dependent on him and contributed to household expenses and his business during your relationship. The children are refusing to provide you any support from the estate.

What You Need: Estate Litigation Services

Why: You have a potential claim for dependant support under Ontario’s Succession Law Reform Act. This requires:

• Filing a court application
• Proving your dependant status
• Demonstrating your financial need
• Negotiating or litigating your entitlement

Hummingbird Lawyer’s Role: We represent you in pursuing your dependant support claim, gathering evidence of your relationship and financial dependence, and advocating for adequate support from the estate.

Scenario 5: Power of Attorney Dispute

Situation: Your aging mother gave power of attorney for property to your sister five years ago. Recently, you’ve noticed significant unexplained withdrawals from mother’s accounts, the sale of valuable jewelry, and changes to investment accounts. Your sister is defensive and refuses to show you any records.

What You Need: Estate Litigation Services

Why: This is an elder law issue involving potential financial abuse. You need to:

• Require your sister to provide an accounting as attorney
• Investigate potential misappropriation
• Potentially apply to revoke the power of attorney
• Protect your mother’s remaining assets

Hummingbird Lawyer’s Role: We assist with POA accounting requirements, investigate financial abuse, and take necessary legal action to protect your mother’s interests.

Scenario 6: Complex Estate with No Disputes

Situation: Your spouse passes away and names you as executor. The estate includes shares in the family business, multiple rental properties, foreign assets in the U.S., and significant investments. The executor is overwhelmed but everyone agrees with the will’s terms.

What You Need: Estate Administration Services

Why: Despite complexity, there are no disputes. The executor needs sophisticated guidance on:

• Handling private company shares
• Real estate transactions across multiple properties
• Cross-border estate issues
• Complex tax planning and filings
• Business valuation and transition

Hummingbird Lawyer’s Role: We provide comprehensive estate administration services for complex estates, coordinating with accountants, business valuators, and U.S. legal counsel as needed.

When You Might Need Both Services

Some situations begin as straightforward estate administration but evolve into litigation, or vice versa. You might need both when:

Starting with Administration, Moving to Litigation

• You begin administering an estate cooperatively, but a beneficiary later challenges the will
• You discover executor misconduct during the administration process
• A dependant support claim is filed against the estate
• Disagreements arise during the distribution phase and accounting

Starting with Litigation, Moving to Administration

• A will challenge is successfully resolved, and administration can proceed
• An executor removal application is granted, and a new executor is appointed who needs administration guidance
• Parties settle their dispute and need guidance enforcing the settlement and completing the administration
• Litigation results in a court order interpreting the will, allowing administration to move forward

Hummingbird Lawyer’s Advantage: Having both estate administration and estate litigation expertise under one roof means seamless transitions as your matter evolves. You don’t need to find a different law firm – we can handle both aspects efficiently.

How to Determine Which Service You Need: A Decision Tree

Ask yourself these questions:

Question 1: Is anyone actively disputing the will’s validity?

• YES → You need Estate Litigation
• NO → Continue to Question 2

Question 2: Is there a disagreement about who should serve as executor?

• YES → You need Estate Litigation
• NO → Continue to Question 3

Question 3: Is the executor refusing to act, provide information, or properly fulfill their duties?

• YES → You need Estate Litigation
• NO → Continue to Question 4

Question 4: Are beneficiaries in significant disagreement about asset distribution or will interpretation?

• YES → You need Estate Litigation
• NO → Continue to Question 5

Question 5: Do you need to make a dependant support claim or defend against one?

• YES → You need Estate Litigation
• NO → Continue to Question 6

Question 6: Is there suspected elder abuse, undue influence, or capacity concerns?

• YES → You need Estate Litigation
• NO → Continue to Question 7

Question 7: Do you simply need guidance on properly administering the estate?

• YES → You need Estate Administration

Red Flags That Indicate Litigation May Be Necessary

Even if you initially thought you only needed administration services, watch for these warning signs:

Will-Related Red Flags

⚠️ The deceased changed their will shortly before death in unexpected ways
⚠️ The deceased had been diagnosed with dementia or cognitive decline
⚠️ Someone had unusual access to the deceased during their final months
⚠️ The will was prepared by someone who benefits under it
⚠️ The will significantly departs from earlier estate plans without clear explanation
⚠️ The will-signing circumstances seem suspicious

Executor Red Flags

⚠️ The executor is not responding to reasonable requests for information
⚠️ Months or years have passed with no progress on estate administration
⚠️ The executor is living in estate property rent-free
⚠️ Estate assets are being sold without proper authorization
⚠️ The executor has conflicts of interest they’re not addressing
⚠️ Estate funds are being used inappropriately
⚠️ The executor is treating beneficiaries unequally

Family Dynamics Red Flags

⚠️ Beneficiaries are not communicating with each other
⚠️ Threats of litigation are being made
⚠️ Someone feels they’ve been unfairly cut out of the will
⚠️ There are accusations of financial exploitation
⚠️ Co-executors cannot agree on basic estate decisions
⚠️ A dependant believes they’re entitled to support from the estate

If you notice these red flags, contact Hummingbird Lawyers immediately for estate litigation advice, even if you initially thought your matter was straightforward.

The Hummingbird Lawyers Approach

Our Estate Administration Services

When you work with Hummingbird Lawyers on estate administration, we:

✓ Provide clear guidance on your duties and responsibilities as executor
✓ Handle probate applications efficiently and accurately
✓ Offer full-service or limited-scope assistance based on your needs
✓ Prepare comprehensive estate accountings
✓ Coordinate with accountants and other professionals
✓ Assist foreign executors with Ontario probate requirements
✓ Help you avoid personal liability by ensuring proper administration
✓ Make complex legal processes understandable and manageable

Our Estate Litigation Services

When you work with Hummingbird Lawyers on estate litigation, we:

✓ Advocate strongly for your rights and interests
✓ Provide strategic advice on the strengths and weaknesses of your case
✓ Handle all types of estate disputes from will challenges to executor removal
✓ Pursue or defend dependant support claims
✓ Address elder law and power of attorney disputes
✓ Seek court directions when needed
✓ Explore settlement options before escalating to full litigation
✓ Represent you confidently in court when necessary

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I start with estate administration and switch to litigation if needed?

Yes, absolutely. Many estate matters begin cooperatively but evolve into disputes. Because Hummingbird Lawyers offers both services, we can seamlessly transition your file if litigation becomes necessary.

How do I know if my situation is serious enough for litigation?

If you’re facing any of the following, litigation may be warranted:

• Active challenges to the will’s validity
• Executor refusing to act or acting improperly
• Significant beneficiary disputes that cannot be resolved
• Suspected financial exploitation or abuse
• Dependant support claims
• Need for court interpretation or direction

Schedule a consultation with Alissa N. Winicki to assess whether litigation is appropriate.

Will estate litigation delay the distribution of the estate?

Often yes, but sometimes litigation is necessary to protect your rights or ensure proper administration. While delays are frustrating, they may be essential to achieving a fair outcome.

Can disputes be resolved without going to court?

Many estate disputes can be resolved through negotiation or mediation. Our litigation lawyers always explore settlement options before proceeding to full court proceedings when possible.

What if I’m the executor and beneficiaries are threatening litigation?

Contact us immediately. We can:

• Review your actions to ensure you’re meeting fiduciary duties
• Advise on proper responses to beneficiary concerns
• Help you provide appropriate accountings
• Defend you if litigation is filed
• Guide you in avoiding actions that could increase your liability

How much do estate administration and litigation services cost?

Estate Administration: Often structured as flat fees for specific services (like probate applications) or hourly rates for ongoing guidance. Costs are generally more predictable.

Estate Litigation: Typically billed hourly due to the unpredictable nature of disputes. We provide cost estimates and keep you informed throughout.

Contact us for a consultation to discuss fees for your specific situation.

I’m not sure which service I need. What should I do?

Schedule a consultation with Hummingbird Lawyers. We’ll assess your situation and provide clear guidance on:

• Whether you need administration or litigation services
• The best approach for your circumstances
• Potential outcomes and timelines
• Cost estimates

Taking the Next Step

Understanding whether you need estate administration or estate litigation services is the first step toward resolving your estate matter effectively.

You Need Estate Administration If:

• You’re an executor seeking guidance on proper estate administration
• The estate has complex assets requiring professional management
• You want to ensure you’re fulfilling your legal obligations correctly
• Beneficiaries are cooperative and there are no significant disputes
• You need help with probate, accountings, or distribution

You Need Estate Litigation If:

• Someone is challenging the will’s validity
• There are disputes about executors or beneficiaries
• The executor is not fulfilling their duties properly
• You’re pursuing or defending a dependant support claim
• There’s suspected elder abuse or financial exploitation
• You need court intervention or direction

Contact Hummingbird Lawyers:
📧 info@hummingbirdlaw.com
📞 905.731.1911

Not Sure Which Service You Need?

Contact Hummingbird Lawyers for a consultation. We’ll assess your situation and direct you to the appropriate service—whether it’s estate administration, estate litigation, or a combination of both.

Why Choose Hummingbird Lawyers for Your Estate Matters?

✓ Comprehensive Expertise: Both estate administration and litigation services under one roof
✓ Experienced Team: Skilled estate lawyers and legal professionals who understand Ontario estate law
✓ Personal Service: We establish trusting, long-term relationships with our clients
✓ Strategic Guidance: Whether administering cooperatively or litigating disputes, we provide clear direction
✓ Efficient Resolution: We work diligently to resolve matters as efficiently as possible
✓ Transparent Communication: We keep you informed every step of the way

Conclusion: Getting the Right Help at the Right Time

The distinction between estate administration and estate litigation is fundamentally about cooperation versus conflict:

• Estate Administration is the cooperative process of fulfilling an executor’s duties and distributing the estate when everyone is generally in agreement.
• Estate Litigation is the adversarial process of resolving disputes through legal proceedings when parties cannot agree.

Both are essential services, and knowing which you need—or when your matter might transition from one to the other—is crucial for achieving the best outcome.

At Hummingbird Lawyers, we’re here to support you whether your estate matter is straightforward or contentious. Our team has the expertise to handle both the orderly administration of estates and the complex disputes that sometimes arise.

Don’t navigate estate matters alone. Contact Hummingbird Lawyers today to discuss your situation and get the right legal support for your needs.

Hummingbird Lawyers LLP
📧 Email: info@hummingbirdlaw.com
📞 Phone: 905.731.1911

Follow us on Facebook.

Follow us on LinkedIn.